﻿ Why doesn't zero divided by zero work
22 May, 2013, 02:50:26
 OmnomIRC You must Register, be logged in and have at least 40 posts to use this shout-box! If it still doesn't show up afterward, it might be that OmnomIRC is disabled for your group or under maintenance.Note: You can also use an IRC client like mIRC, X-Chat or Mibbit to connect to an EFnet server and #omnimaga.

 Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down
 Author Topic: Why doesn't zero divided by zero work -  (Read 2254 times) 0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Dingus
LV4 Regular (Next: 200)

Offline

Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 10:39:24
Date Registered: 21 March, 2011, 01:01:58
Posts: 129

Total Post Ratings: +13

 « Reply #30 on: 25 February, 2012, 17:20:42 » 0

That has been asked and answered.  Did you read my post?  BTW, the opposite of infinity is minus infinity.

Quote

Anyway I personally have no clue why 0/0 doesn't work, though, but what I think is that 0 by itself is nothing, so basically you divide nothing by nothing. However I think it's also because you multiply nothing by the infinity, but I'm not sure if the opposite of "infinity" is "nothing".
 Logged
aeTIos
You got stair'd!
LV12 Extreme Poster (Next: 5000)

Offline

Gender:
Date Registered: 15 September, 2010, 06:00:00
Location: Netherlands, Overijssel
Posts: 3118

Total Post Ratings: +120

 « Reply #31 on: 25 February, 2012, 17:25:02 » 0

So that implies 0/0=1 which is mathemagically correct. (x/x=1)
hmmm...
 Logged

If something above sounds rude, feel free to vote it down, it was not meant to be rude<<lolol
--Always stay relAXEd!--

Spoiler for Hidden:

[

Spoiler for Still Alive:
This was a triumph.
I'm making a note here: HUGE SUCCESS.
It's hard to overstate my satisfaction.

Aperture Science:
We do what we must because we can.
For the good of all of us
Except the ones who are dead.

But there's no sense crying over every mistake
You just keep on trying till you run out of cake
And the science gets done and you make a neat gun
For the people who are still alive.

I'm not even angry.
I'm being so sincere right now.
Even though you broke my heart and killed me.
And tore me to pieces.
And threw every piece into a fire.
As they burned it hurt because
I was so happy for you.

Now these points of data make a beautiful line
And we're out of beta we're releasing on time.
So I'm GLaD I got burned think of all the things we learned
For the people who are still alive.

I think I prefer to stay inside.
Maybe Black Mesa -
THAT WAS A JOKE. HA HA, FAT CHANCE.
Anyway, this cake is great:
It's so delicious and moist.

Look at me still talking when there's science to do.
When I look out there it makes me GLaD I'm not you.
I've experiments to run there is research to be done
On the people who are still alive

And believe me I am still alive.
I'm doing science and I'm still alive.
I feel FANTASTIC and I'm still alive.
While you're dying I'll be still alive.
And when you're dead I will be still alive.

Still alive
Still alive
Dingus
LV4 Regular (Next: 200)

Offline

Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 10:39:24
Date Registered: 21 March, 2011, 01:01:58
Posts: 129

Total Post Ratings: +13

 « Reply #32 on: 25 February, 2012, 18:18:24 » 0

Yeah, we're learning Calculus (mostly differential atm) in Year 12, and we had a long discussion about limits.
The limit technically does not exist at the given value e.g.: lim h->0 f(x)=3x^2+7x-5.
At h=0 the equation is undefined as we're dividing by 0 (The answer could be infinity, for all we know, or it could be 9000.00000032), but the point of Calculus (well at least this part of calculus) is that we are to find the theoretical derivative of the equation when h=0, even though it technically does not exist.

Hope that made some sense, and I may have made a mistake.

Huh?  For continuous functions, i.e., functions whose graphs don't have a break in them and can be drawn without lifting your pencil from the paper, the limit of f(x) as x approaches a is f(a), the value of the function at a.  Furthermore, all polynomials are continuous. So technically what you said is incorrect for polynomials but can be correct for other functions which have a discontinuity where the limit is being taken.  For example, the rational function (x^2-x)/(x-1) has a discontinuity at x=1 because the function is not defined and doesn't exist there because of division by zero (the denominator is zero), however the limit as x approaches one does exist and is one.  You can see from the graph, that as x approaches one from either direction it gets closer and closer to one but "at" one we know the function doesn't exist.  On the other hand, the polynomial function x^2-x exists at and is continuous at x=1 so the limit of f(x)=x^2-x as x approaches one is f(1) (the value of the function AT the value that x is approaching) which is zero.
 Logged
ACagliano

Offline

Last Login: 14 May, 2013, 13:02:38
Date Registered: 03 July, 2009, 01:06:06
Posts: 764

Total Post Ratings: +29

 « Reply #33 on: 25 February, 2012, 18:22:24 » 0

Would there be a way to create a calc hook that enables it to automatically figure out a limit if the denominatior = 0
 Logged

-ACagliano
TI-Basic software developer

My Website

Current Projects
----------------------------
1. Legend of Zelda "Revenge of Ganon"
-maps: 100%
-graphics engine: 20% (sprites)
-AI engine: 0%
-event scripts: 60% (text left)
-walking engine: 100%
-miscellaneous: 40%
-total progress:  54%

Dingus
LV4 Regular (Next: 200)

Offline

Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 10:39:24
Date Registered: 21 March, 2011, 01:01:58
Posts: 129

Total Post Ratings: +13

 « Reply #34 on: 25 February, 2012, 18:28:13 » 0

So that implies 0/0=1 which is mathemagically correct. (x/x=1)
hmmm...
No, 0/0 is undefined therefore x/x is undefined (does not exist) at x=0!  Division by zero is not a valid mathematical operation and a zero denominator is division by zero.  In a course on groups, rings and fields you can learn why.  For now, just accept that division by zero is just not a valid mathematical operation.
 Logged
aeTIos
You got stair'd!
LV12 Extreme Poster (Next: 5000)

Offline

Gender:
Date Registered: 15 September, 2010, 06:00:00
Location: Netherlands, Overijssel
Posts: 3118

Total Post Ratings: +120

 « Reply #35 on: 25 February, 2012, 18:28:52 » 0

Ok.
 Logged

If something above sounds rude, feel free to vote it down, it was not meant to be rude<<lolol
--Always stay relAXEd!--

Spoiler for Hidden:

[

Spoiler for Still Alive:
This was a triumph.
I'm making a note here: HUGE SUCCESS.
It's hard to overstate my satisfaction.

Aperture Science:
We do what we must because we can.
For the good of all of us
Except the ones who are dead.

But there's no sense crying over every mistake
You just keep on trying till you run out of cake
And the science gets done and you make a neat gun
For the people who are still alive.

I'm not even angry.
I'm being so sincere right now.
Even though you broke my heart and killed me.
And tore me to pieces.
And threw every piece into a fire.
As they burned it hurt because
I was so happy for you.

Now these points of data make a beautiful line
And we're out of beta we're releasing on time.
So I'm GLaD I got burned think of all the things we learned
For the people who are still alive.

I think I prefer to stay inside.
Maybe Black Mesa -
THAT WAS A JOKE. HA HA, FAT CHANCE.
Anyway, this cake is great:
It's so delicious and moist.

Look at me still talking when there's science to do.
When I look out there it makes me GLaD I'm not you.
I've experiments to run there is research to be done
On the people who are still alive

And believe me I am still alive.
I'm doing science and I'm still alive.
I feel FANTASTIC and I'm still alive.
While you're dying I'll be still alive.
And when you're dead I will be still alive.

Still alive
Still alive
AngelFish
This is my custom title
LV12 Extreme Poster (Next: 5000)

Offline

Gender:
Date Registered: 15 August, 2010, 09:18:54
Posts: 3188

Total Post Ratings: +218

 « Reply #36 on: 25 February, 2012, 18:45:35 » 0

Guys, please no "divide by zero" funny pictures on this topic.

Somebody gave me a good reason that 0/0 isn't valid.  But I can't remember what it was.

Let's represent 0/0 as something else, namely 0*(1/0). This makes it obvious what the main problem is. Division by 0, of *any* number, whether a real or a rational number, simply isn't defined in the standard system of reals. It's not immediately obvious why this is so. 0 doesn't appear to be a special number (besides being the null quantity) until we look at the definition of a field, which the set of real numbers forms when combined with the operations of addition, negation, multiplication, and multiplicative inversion (Finding A=B-1). Basically, 0 is what is called the additive identity, which means that any number from the field can be added to it and you will get the same number back out. A+additive identity=A in any field F. The important part of being defined as the additive identity is that by definition, division by the additive identity is undefined in any non-trivial field. It's just a matter of definition. Things go funky when you allow it and inconsistencies creep in, such as being able to "prove" that 1=2 in the real numbers.

TL;DR 0/0 is undefined because convention says it's undefined to make things work out properly. You can say 0/0 is whatever you want, but as soon as you do so, everything else falls apart.

Also, now that I've written this, I see that adriweb beat me to it with a well timed Wikipedia quote.
 « Last Edit: 25 February, 2012, 18:48:26 by Qwerty.55 » Logged

∂²Ψ    -(2m(V(x)-E)Ψ
---  = -------------
∂x²        ℏ²Ψ
Dingus
LV4 Regular (Next: 200)

Offline

Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 10:39:24
Date Registered: 21 March, 2011, 01:01:58
Posts: 129

Total Post Ratings: +13

 « Reply #37 on: 26 February, 2012, 02:51:36 » 0

Guys, please no "divide by zero" funny pictures on this topic.

Somebody gave me a good reason that 0/0 isn't valid.  But I can't remember what it was.

Let's represent 0/0 as something else, namely 0*(1/0). This makes it obvious what the main problem is. Division by 0, of *any* number, whether a real or a rational number, simply isn't defined in the standard system of reals. It's not immediately obvious why this is so. 0 doesn't appear to be a special number (besides being the null quantity) until we look at the definition of a field, which the set of real numbers forms when combined with the operations of addition, negation, multiplication, and multiplicative inversion (Finding A=B-1). Basically, 0 is what is called the additive identity, which means that any number from the field can be added to it and you will get the same number back out. A+additive identity=A in any field F. The important part of being defined as the additive identity is that by definition, division by the additive identity is undefined in any non-trivial field. It's just a matter of definition. Things go funky when you allow it and inconsistencies creep in, such as being able to "prove" that 1=2 in the real numbers.

TL;DR 0/0 is undefined because convention says it's undefined to make things work out properly. You can say 0/0 is whatever you want, but as soon as you do so, everything else falls apart.

Also, now that I've written this, I see that adriweb beat me to it with a well timed
Quote

Excellent explanation.  Thank you.
 Logged
Jonius7
aka jhgenius
LV10 31337 u53r (Next: 2000)

Offline

Gender:
Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 06:58:52
Date Registered: 03 September, 2010, 02:50:11
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Posts: 1743

Total Post Ratings: +50

 « Reply #38 on: 26 February, 2012, 10:38:02 » 0

I'm confused, the whole thing has just been quoted...

Oh, I see at the very bottom inside the quote.

In response to Qwerty's explanation, 0/0 does not fit in with the concepts of mathematics and therefore "everything else" (the mathematical concepts) falls apart when you try to take 0/0 into account. That is why 0/0 is undefined.
Great explanation.
 « Last Edit: 26 February, 2012, 10:38:37 by Jonius7 » Logged

 Userbars.com is down?+9001 Intermediate TI-nspire Basic ProgrammerProgrammed some CASIO Basic in the pastDJ_O Music Discographist Userbars for these coming... in the process
My Released and Announced Projects (Updated 2013/01/29)
TI-nspire BASIC
TI-nspire Hold 'em | Health Bar | Scissors Paper Rock | Battle of 16s (stalled) | sTIck RPG (stalled) | Monopoly (stalled)

TI-nspire Lua
Numstrat | TI-nspire Hold 'em Lua | Terraria (coming soon)
Axe Parser
Doodle God (stalled while I go and learn some Axe)

Spoiler for Other Stuff:

To add it to your signature just copy and paste the code below into your sig and you'll become an instant supporter of my website!
 1 [URL=http://www.jhgenius01.webs.com][IMG]http://s1.bild.me/bilder/060112/3684792HDuserbaruser.png[/IMG][/URL]
Spoiler for My TI-nspire Basic Programs (Updated 2012/04/15):
***List of Programs in the TI-nspire Stadium***
Group Release 2012/04/07 on omnimaga.org

Games
Noteable Release    ticalc.org Release Development/Not Publicly Released
2010/05/08 TI-nspire Hold 'em
2012/04/07 v1.1.2   2012/04/10 v1.1.3  2012/04/14 v1.2.1
2010/08/03 Cosmic Legions
2012/04/07 v0.2.2.2 (1st Release)
2010/08/12 Battle of 16s
2012/04/07 v0.2.7
2010/09/10 Health Bar
2012/04/07 v1.2     2012/04/02 v1.0
2010/12/04 sTIck RPG
2012/04/07 v0.1.5.2
2011/01/09 Monopoly
2012/04/07 v0.16    (1st Release)
2012/04/09 Scissors Paper Rock
2012/04/14 v0.8.1

Miscellaneous
2010/11/07 中文 (Chinese) Demonstration
2012/04/07 v1.3     (1st Release)

Potential/Minor Programs
2010/09/26 Shanghai Metro
2012/04/07 v0.2     (1st Release)
2010/12/22 TI-nspire Programming Tutorials
2012/04/07 v0.1     (1st Release)
2010/12/28 Casino Games
Was not released.
2012/04/07 v0.0.4   (1st Release)
2012/03/22 Hierarchy
2012/04/07 v0.01

Demo Programs (some may become Potential Programs)
2010/06/23 Monopoly (Board)
2012/04/07 Prototype
2010/07/14 Strategy Battle
2012/04/07 v0.12
2010/10/05 JRPG
2012/04/07 v0.2
2010/11/02 PlotGrid
2012/04/07 v0.2
2010/11/24 civilizaTIon™
2012/04/07 v0.11

Purely Informational
2012/04/07 v2
Created to list significant releases of my programs. A page similar to this List of Programs in the TI-nspire Stadium was included in the documentation of most of my programs until sometime in Late 2011/Early 2012.

All games and programs coded in TI-nspire Basic.
Last Updated 14 April 2012

jhgenius01.webs.com
Will be moving! Stay tuned for updates.
Spoiler for Progress of Doodle God Axe:
2011/12/21 4% - Progress Suspended, ideas of graphical sprites still uncertain
Spoiler for Other Other You Know What Other Stuff I'm Talking About Stuff Stuff (Updated 2012/01/17):
phenomist
LV4 Regular (Next: 200)

Offline

Last Login: 13 December, 2012, 08:27:04
Date Registered: 14 January, 2011, 02:56:20
Posts: 132

Total Post Ratings: +44

 « Reply #39 on: 28 February, 2012, 04:34:02 » 0

Was going to throw in L'Hopital's rule, but there's already an enlightening section on that on page 2.

It all depends on the context of the 0's, really, and simply putting "0" isn't giving the context. Hence its undefinability.
 Logged

Level Designer for Graviter

[Disclaimer: I can't program for my life.]
Jonius7
aka jhgenius
LV10 31337 u53r (Next: 2000)

Offline

Gender:
Last Login: 20 May, 2013, 06:58:52
Date Registered: 03 September, 2010, 02:50:11
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Posts: 1743

Total Post Ratings: +50

 « Reply #40 on: 28 February, 2012, 07:00:32 » 0

Well 0 is a number but when you try and divide by itself the answer cannot be defined simply in mathematical terms.
Hence, it's kinda out of the realm of mathematics that we understand.
 « Last Edit: 28 February, 2012, 07:00:58 by Jonius7 » Logged

 Userbars.com is down?+9001 Intermediate TI-nspire Basic ProgrammerProgrammed some CASIO Basic in the pastDJ_O Music Discographist Userbars for these coming... in the process
My Released and Announced Projects (Updated 2013/01/29)
TI-nspire BASIC
TI-nspire Hold 'em | Health Bar | Scissors Paper Rock | Battle of 16s (stalled) | sTIck RPG (stalled) | Monopoly (stalled)

TI-nspire Lua
Numstrat | TI-nspire Hold 'em Lua | Terraria (coming soon)
Axe Parser
Doodle God (stalled while I go and learn some Axe)

Spoiler for Other Stuff:

To add it to your signature just copy and paste the code below into your sig and you'll become an instant supporter of my website!
 1 [URL=http://www.jhgenius01.webs.com][IMG]http://s1.bild.me/bilder/060112/3684792HDuserbaruser.png[/IMG][/URL]
Spoiler for My TI-nspire Basic Programs (Updated 2012/04/15):
***List of Programs in the TI-nspire Stadium***
Group Release 2012/04/07 on omnimaga.org

Games
Noteable Release    ticalc.org Release Development/Not Publicly Released
2010/05/08 TI-nspire Hold 'em
2012/04/07 v1.1.2   2012/04/10 v1.1.3  2012/04/14 v1.2.1
2010/08/03 Cosmic Legions
2012/04/07 v0.2.2.2 (1st Release)
2010/08/12 Battle of 16s
2012/04/07 v0.2.7
2010/09/10 Health Bar
2012/04/07 v1.2     2012/04/02 v1.0
2010/12/04 sTIck RPG
2012/04/07 v0.1.5.2
2011/01/09 Monopoly
2012/04/07 v0.16    (1st Release)
2012/04/09 Scissors Paper Rock
2012/04/14 v0.8.1

Miscellaneous
2010/11/07 中文 (Chinese) Demonstration
2012/04/07 v1.3     (1st Release)

Potential/Minor Programs
2010/09/26 Shanghai Metro
2012/04/07 v0.2     (1st Release)
2010/12/22 TI-nspire Programming Tutorials
2012/04/07 v0.1     (1st Release)
2010/12/28 Casino Games
Was not released.
2012/04/07 v0.0.4   (1st Release)
2012/03/22 Hierarchy
2012/04/07 v0.01

Demo Programs (some may become Potential Programs)
2010/06/23 Monopoly (Board)
2012/04/07 Prototype
2010/07/14 Strategy Battle
2012/04/07 v0.12
2010/10/05 JRPG
2012/04/07 v0.2
2010/11/02 PlotGrid
2012/04/07 v0.2
2010/11/24 civilizaTIon™
2012/04/07 v0.11

Purely Informational
2012/04/07 v2
Created to list significant releases of my programs. A page similar to this List of Programs in the TI-nspire Stadium was included in the documentation of most of my programs until sometime in Late 2011/Early 2012.

All games and programs coded in TI-nspire Basic.
Last Updated 14 April 2012

jhgenius01.webs.com
Will be moving! Stay tuned for updates.
Spoiler for Progress of Doodle God Axe:
2011/12/21 4% - Progress Suspended, ideas of graphical sprites still uncertain
Spoiler for Other Other You Know What Other Stuff I'm Talking About Stuff Stuff (Updated 2012/01/17):
 Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up