Omnimaga

Calculator Community => Other Calculators => Topic started by: kyllopardiun on December 14, 2010, 02:19:23 pm

Title: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: kyllopardiun on December 14, 2010, 02:19:23 pm
Well, I was just looking at some google pages ...
and saw at least 3 Nspire CAS+ for sell in some sites [including ebay]

I know it isn't upgradable [in theory] to the new OSes

but, it still much cheaper than almost every other calculator with similar functions such as taylor() among others.

So my question is: Is it worth to pay 170 BRL =~[100 USD] =~ [80 euros] for it?

It would be for college study.

And another question, but this I think will not be easy to reply as only someone with it could try ...
How 'impossible' is to upgrade it's OS?
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: fb39ca4 on December 14, 2010, 08:47:20 pm
If it's just for math, it should do. You could also look at hp calcs, i think those also include a cas. As for os upgrades, you would probably need a NAND programmer, unless there is a way to download stuff over rs232. You may or may not have to factor the rsa key, because the os was never intended to be upgraded.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: AngelFish on December 14, 2010, 08:49:04 pm
If you just want to do math, get an HP and learn RPN, as well as HFAA.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: kyllopardiun on December 15, 2010, 09:45:48 am
fb39ca4, yes it's just for Math/Calculus as for playing/programming I have my nspire clickpad ...
and the upgrade was just a thought, because they appear to be quite similar for me, as the most functions are the same in both.

If you just want to do math, get an HP and learn RPN, as well as HFAA.

It's cheaper the CAS+ than an average hp50g,
Well i know some RPN, but I couldn't understand what does HFAA stands for as google said:
"Hardanger Fiddle Association of America" among others weirds results.

Also, I don't really like hp50g, i wish there was some ti 89 titanium+ ...
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: NeoCrisis on December 15, 2010, 10:59:15 am
sorry guys, but wat's a CAS+ ??? here in France, we've got only regular Nspires and Nspire CAS, but no Nspire CAS+ 8|
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: calc84maniac on December 15, 2010, 11:56:42 am
sorry guys, but wat's a CAS+ ??? here in France, we've got only regular Nspires and Nspire CAS, but no Nspire CAS+ 8|
It's the TI-Nspire prototype. It's not available in retail stores, only on places like eBay
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: AngelFish on December 15, 2010, 12:29:16 pm
If you just want to do math, get an HP and learn RPN, as well as HFAA.

It's cheaper the CAS+ than an average hp50g,
Well i know some RPN, but I couldn't understand what does HFAA stands for as google said:
"Hardanger Fiddle Association of America" among others weirds results.

Also, I don't really like hp50g, i wish there was some ti 89 titanium+ ...

"How Fun Acronyms Are" ;)
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: critor on December 15, 2010, 02:19:57 pm
sorry guys, but wat's a CAS+ ??? here in France, we've got only regular Nspires and Nspire CAS, but no Nspire CAS+ 8|

The Nspire CAS+ prototype has been widely tested in France in 2006-2007 school year.
We've regularly mentionned it since on www.TI-Bank.fr .

And as you were told here, the CAS is far better than the CAS+.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on December 15, 2010, 02:22:20 pm
The CAS isn't even sold over here. O.O

Also people be careful when buying Nspires on Ebay. Do not get a + unless you only need it for math, your teacher doesn't mind if you don't use the latest OS and that you don't plan to use it for 3rd party development. Also, check the picture on Ebay to make sure it's really a CAS you're buying, not a CAS+. Some people may try to pass CAS+ calcs as CAS to fool buyers.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: fb39ca4 on December 15, 2010, 04:25:37 pm
Since you have a clickpad nspire, you don't have anything to lose getting the cas+. Plus, it's nice to have two calcs, one for school and one for home.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: Jonius7 on December 17, 2010, 09:57:23 pm
with the cas+, keep in mind that there would be hardly any, or not at all any support for the model since it is a prototype pre-release model.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: kyllopardiun on December 19, 2010, 12:10:30 pm
with the cas+, keep in mind that there would be hardly any, or not at all any support for the model since it is a prototype pre-release model.

I won't get any support neither for my calc as TI hardly reply any e-mail [my only support is here and other forums]
and isn't easy to find any retail store about calcs [except hp] down here...

[It doesn't matter for my teachers which calculator I am using, and they don't provide us any app/document for calc]
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on December 19, 2010, 12:44:29 pm
Ah ok, I guess you should be fine, then. The only issue with the CAS+ is that it has no programming capabilities at all, like OS 1.1, so if you want math programs then you can't use that calc at school.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: NeoCrisis on December 21, 2010, 08:31:17 am
I'd prefer to keep the Nspire CAS I will have for Christmas ;) if I do not persuade my stepfather to not buy me a new calc, I'll keep the Nspire at home, but I already persuaded him that I'll be fine, so :/

But, if it's less interesting than regular and CAS Nspires, why is it called CAS+ ?!
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on December 21, 2010, 03:42:17 pm
No clue why, I guess the + was added to differentiate those calcs from the official ones and they didn't want to release the CAS+ and make people wonder where is the CAS. Some people sometimes ask if there was ever a TI-84 regular before the 84+.

ALso I'm glad you're getting a new calc soon. YOu're still gonna be able to work on SimpleCS, right? Because the CAS has no 84+ emulation...
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: NeoCrisis on December 22, 2010, 09:16:53 am
I'll be working on SimpleCS whatever happens, I'll have Wabbit allowed to run on my computer, so no problem about it ;) I'm even thinking of tranlsating SimpleCS to the Nspires' programming language, but I don't remember if there's a BASIC language in those ???
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: kyllopardiun on December 22, 2010, 11:16:17 am
I'll be working on SimpleCS whatever happens, I'll have Wabbit allowed to run on my computer, so no problem about it ;) I'm even thinking of tranlsating SimpleCS to the Nspires' programming language, but I don't remember if there's a BASIC language in those ???

Yes and not, as the basic isn't the same and has less features..
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: NeoCrisis on December 22, 2010, 11:17:24 am
I know that there's C and ARM ASM, but there's surely a more-or-less easy programming language (easier than C :P )
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on December 22, 2010, 11:01:12 pm
Not yet, currently all we can do is ARM ASM and C, as well as the limited TI-BASIC. Maybe in a few years we'll also have Axe for the Nspire. :D
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: fb39ca4 on December 24, 2010, 04:36:15 pm
I know that there's C and ARM ASM, but there's surely a more-or-less easy programming language (easier than C :P )
Well, there's java, but idk how easy it is. If you can get a language to compile for arm, theoretically, it can be made to work on nspire.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on December 26, 2010, 05:22:32 pm
There's Java for the Nspire??? I never knew about that. I thought it was only on 68K calcs (QS Moka)?
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: calcdude84se on December 26, 2010, 05:31:01 pm
Some ARM processors can run Java bytecode directly. I'm not sure the one in the Nspire can, but I'm not certain.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: jnesselr on December 26, 2010, 05:55:00 pm
That is awesome! I would code anything for the NSpire in C, probably.  I need an NSpire...
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: fb39ca4 on December 26, 2010, 08:38:19 pm
Some ARM processors can run Java bytecode directly. I'm not sure the one in the Nspire can, but I'm not certain.
Yes, the nspire can. I remember there was java support in ndless 1.0 but idk what happened to it in 1.7.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: calcforth on December 27, 2010, 07:02:29 am
Yes, the nspire can. I remember there was java support in ndless 1.0 but idk what happened to it in 1.7.
Java support in ndless 1.0 included Java application to run in PC, it had nothing to do with on-calc Java. And I doubt Jazelle (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jazelle) is included: it's optional component in ARM9 (and nSpire is ARM9) so I doubt TI paid to include it.

You can probably port Dalvik (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalvik_(software)) (which is not technically JVM, but is compatible with Java language), but even this will be significant effort.
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: supergems on February 17, 2011, 05:01:54 am
Also, I don't really like hp50g, i wish there was some ti 89 titanium+ ...

Ahahah TI89T!?
 
The CAS of the HP 50g is more flexible, try to calculate this expression with CASIO ClassPad, TI-NSPRE CAS and TI 89T/V200, you fail in any way:

'ABS(\GS(K=1,+\oo,((1+i)/2)^K))' ('\GS' is the summation symbol and 'i' is the imaginary unit)

using the HP 50g we can do it with these steps:
 
'\GS(K=1,N,((1+i)/2)^K)' EVAL SIMPLIFY
'(-(i*EXP((2*N*LN(2)+i*\pi*N)/4))+i*EXP(N*LN(2)))/EXP(N*LN(2))'
'N=\oo'
'lim'
result: 'i'
and finally we get 1 with ABS.
 
Partial fraction:
 
HP 50g
'(3*X^3+2*X^2+X+1)/(4*X^2+2*X+1)' PARTFRAC (in COMPLEX mode) --> '3/4*X+1/8+(7*i*\v/3/12/(4*X+(1+i*\v/3))-7*i*\v/3/12/(4*X+(1-i*\v/3)))', where "\v/" is square root symbol.
 
TI-NSPIRE CAS is unable to do the partial fraction expansion when the denominator has complex roots!
expand((3*X^3+2*X^2+X+1)/(4*X^2+2*X+1)) = 7/(8*(4*x^2+2*x+1))+3*x/4+1/8
In the TI89T/V200 calculators expand() is buggy ahahah :P .
Title: Re: Nspire CAS+: how worth is it?
Post by: DJ Omnimaga on February 17, 2011, 09:28:04 am
Well first, calm down, and secondly maybe he didn't care about the CAS when he chose his 89T. It doesn't mean you should laugh at him for prefering the 89T over the HP-50G. Also The 89T may have a crappier CAS, but almost nobody develop games for the HP-50G anymore. Also this topic is rather old.

The next time you suggest the HP-50G to a forum member in a thread that has nothing to do with HP or say anything bad against TI/Casio calcs in a topic that isn't related to it or simply try to start a TI vs Casio or TI vs HP flame war like in almost everyone of your post on Casiocalc.org, your forum account will be deleted and your IP will be banned forever. We won't tolerate such shit over here.