Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Nanamar

Pages: [1]
3
What the heck? O.O

(Btw it's not me. Not sure why someone would try to impersonate me and praise the Nspire under my name ._.)

Probably the NSA or perhaps TI? :-)

To get back to the subject,

Personally I'm a little disappointed with my TI Nspire CX CAS.

I guess I should have known better, I did try it for some hours in the windows emulator. But the win emulator did hide two of the major flaws:

1. I used my mouse, not the calculators lacking trackpad

2. the stupid colour of "selected text", invisible!

The calculator is by no means "bad" or subpar, but not as great as I had wished.

Since I don't want to buy 3 calculators this spring, I'm trying to decide between the Classpad II and Prime. So let's keep the thread going!

Happy Friday everyone!

4
Hi DJ Omnimaga!

The issue with the ClassPad though is the speed. If you run a program and have to wait 6 minutes 40 seconds for your result when the TI-Nspire CAS and HP Prime can do it in a single second or less, there is a serious problem. Also, when I run a program then exit, there is a 30-60 seconds loading before I can even do anything else.

Graphing, on the other hand, isn't that slow, and I love the touchscreen for it. I don't understand why they decided to go with a resistive screen and a stylus, though. We're in 2014, not 1999.

Casio really need to get their act up together and optimize the Basic interpreter. There's no reason why a 50-200 MHz calculator takes 13 times times longer to execute a program than on a 15 MHz one. That said, rewriting the basic interpreter all from scratch would result into a buggy one until they finally found all the bugs, as seen on the new HP calcs.

That said, I and many other people here are kinda biased because Omnimaga is a site almost entirely dedicated to game development and gaming and people here happen to prefer TI-BASIC-like languages, so they'll generally choose the calc which has the fastest one.

Understood. My selection of the Classpad is based on getting the calculator that helps you perform the best on exams, disregarding coding and gaming!

That said, I only own the Classpad I. And from what I see in this video
http://youtu.be/7VppXuhHO_g?t=11m42s
http://youtu.be/7VppXuhHO_g?t=14m5s
the keyboard menus in the Classpad II seems less detailed, and not as good. You can't do as much without flipping betweens submenus.

And the naming: "Math1, Math2..." is far from good.

But they've moved the backspace button to a better place!


The prices I mentioned can be had, also in France, from EU Internet vendors, then adding 10-20 EUR for shipping.

For the Classpad II I guess it would be fair to add an additional 20 EUR for rechargeable batteries and a charger.

Regarding math performance I found a nice video:

http://youtu.be/DHRsvSTGiBc?t=16m15s

integral(e^x^3,x,0,6)

his results: (a selection)
HP Prime <00:00
Casio Classpad II 00:03
TI-89 Ti 00:14

my own results:
TI-89 (std) 00:20
HP 48GX 01:45
Casio Classpad 330 (not+) 00:08
TI-nspire CX CAS <00:01

5
Do you mean the ClassPad II? Because I think the topic starter wants some game programmability too, which is a serious issue on the FX-cp400 (extremely slow Basic language compared to Nspire Lua and HP PPL). If you mean the Casio PRIZM (FX-cg10/20), then that has some better programmability (LuaZM, SH4 assembly and C, although all of them can only be done on the computer). The ClassPad II is also very expensive unless you live in Canada.

I meant the Casio classpad. I have the 330 Plus. The Casio fx CP400 seems to be about the same calculator but with colour display.

Since the OP mentioned he was going to use the calculator for School, this is why I mentioned the Classpad. I think it (if allowed) is the best calculator for school usage - disregarding games and coding. Let me tell why:

____HP Prime__________
From my experience in the PC-emulator and what I've read this product is a little "rough around the edges". It has diffuse error messages. In a situation where your exam results determine the next semesters student financing you can't have your calculator fail on you or be confusing. Adding to this, why no option for multi line editing? A long math expression results in really bad screen area utilization, a thin line - forcing scrolling. The HP 48 had multi line editing, and even an option to let the 1st stack item to show itself on multi lines! This might be a fun coding calculator, but from what I've seen this far, it's not the best school calculator.


______TI-Nspire CX CAS__________
I recently bought this calculator and have given it quite some time to learn it.
Major complaints:
* The user experienced leaves me feeling constrained. Locked in. Not pleasant. Like using windows with a keyboard and bad trackpad and then some (cryptic shortcuts).
* With the 3.6 software the freaking indication (colour) of what is selected is almost invisible against the white background (from a ordinary users viewpoint). Since "show selected text" is also used when you backspace editing math expressions this is very irritating. Doesn't TI bother to test their new software on users?
* Three types of menus in most given situations. doc\/, menu and ctrl-menu. Why not four .... ? ....
* no easy way to view and manage variables
* Requires you to memorize stupid shortcuts (se home/end below + many more) to get around a flawed (?) user interface with any kind of flow. This is so much worse than the TI-89.

Minor complaints:
* too small buttons for +-*/
* ctrl 7 & 1 for home and end, why?
* should have laplace transforms (my exams require "clean" calculator)
* you can't do 1/matrix, only matrix^(-1)...

The best thing I can say of the CX CAS is that it looks good and has a great undo functionality, and it can do multi line editing if you copy paste into notes page.

Having a TI-89 that I really like, I must say that the TI-Nspire CX CAS seems to be the calculators equivalent of Windows 8...

Or you could say the CX CAS is the calculators equivalent of "the teachers pet", it does everything a teacher wants - only to compensate it is far from the brightest "kid" in class....



_____Casio Classpad_____ (I have 330 plus)
* The user experience is positive. My face gets a smile like the one on the plastic cover. If you've got a GUI you should have a good pointing device, and you have that with the pen. Drag to copy. Point to edit etc, everything a smooth flow. Doing a box zoom is one click and then make the box (point drag pen up). I will admit that the GUI can have a "sharp learning curve", but when you get it it is good. Example: I still haven't figured out how to shrink a matrix on the CX CAS. Here you simply mark and backspace unwanted rows/columns.
* Can do multi line editing if you do copy paste into editor window. Start editor, then a main window. Then you can jump and resize between the two rather smooth.
* I haven't seen a (major) bug yet.
* Can do laplace.
* Regarding price fx CP400 is only marginally more expensive than CX CAS and Prime, all can be had for around 130-150 EUR in the EU. The 330 is even cheaper.



So right now I would recommend the Classpad, but who knows, next week I might say get the TI! :-) (But MAN they have to fix the colour of selected text!!)

I found a short unboxing video for those that haven't seen the "colour classpad":


6
...

Thank you for your detailed answer!


7
OP: Also give the advanced Casio a look. Can do Laplace which the TI can't. Prime can. Casio Pen interface is sweet, but menus can be ....  :crazy:

8
General Calculator Help / TI-nSpire CX CAS , noob user questions + rants
« on: February 09, 2014, 10:06:16 pm »
So I got the CX CAS recently, and I've been using it a bit.

Questions:
* Handheld Setup->Font Size : It doesn't seem to change the font size of the "stack"? What does it change? And did it change the "stack" font size before I upgraded the firmware to the latest?

* Can I "wash away" math print and get an expression in full "programming style" syntax?

* Marking / selecting text. MAN, how did they ever choose such a stupid colour for showing selected text? It's practically invisible against the white background! It is clearly visible if I rotate my CX 180 degrees (yaw), or roll it a bit...  I went as far as thinking that my display was mounted wrong. Is there a way to change this selected text colour?


Rants (please feel free to comment)
* WHY have they made the access and viewing of variables and functions (when you plot) so hard? What's wrong with a list on which you can select, delete and preview variables and functions? This is SO stupid! It took me long to figure out how to delete a function!

* I found myself feeling "strained" using the CX CAS. At first I thought it was the CX CAS that was "stupid", but probably it is my brain that is slow to learn. I finally did a timed trial entering a long math expresion. The CX CAS was quicker than the rest! (330, 48GX, 89)


9
I'm not completely sure what you want. Do you want to be able to edit them in a text format on multiple lines (meaning that "1/2" appears as 1/2), or do you want to edit them in multiple lines in a mathprint-like mode (meaning that "1/2" appears as )? If you want the former, many calculators will be able to do that, but I don't really know much model names. The 83+/34+ series do that, though, and iirc the 83/83+ calculators don't have an other input mode. Your TI-89 may be capable of this as well.
If you want multiple lines in a mathprint-like mode, then I don't know a single calculator that lets you do that, but someone else might know one.

Hi ben_g!

Thank you for your answer!

I just want to use more rows! Disregarding if it is in infix notation or mathematical display (TI-lingo: math print).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculator_input_methods#Mathematical_display


The TI-89 won't let you edit anything in "mathprint". And, it won't let you edit in more than one row, unless you use the Text Editor.

So, I played around with the CX CAS emulator a little bit more. And I think I've figured it out!

doc->insert->Notes
menu->insert->math box

Now you've got an area that does word wrap math expressions! YES!!

And it even has Math Print.

So it ticks even that box!

Multi line, word wrapping editing in Math Print. Nice! This is what I wanted!

I still would like to know how to force the CX CAS to convert Math Print into Infix Notation, for example editing matrixes would sometimes be easier this way.

Any ideas how to do this?

Two more questions:

So the only manuals TI has released for the CX CAS is the TI-NspireCAS_ReferenceGuide_EN and TI-Nspire_CX-HH_GettingStarted_EN? I really miss something between a quick start and reference!

And, how about the HP Prime, any ideas there for multi line editing of math expressions?

10
HI!

Background:
Ever since I went from the HP 48GX to the TI-89 I was really disturbed by the TI-89:s inability to let me edit a really long calculation (34+53-343/34...) on multiple lines (word wrapping)!

The HP 48GX lets you full screen multi line edit a '3242+34324+324+23+4...' object with leftshift->edit.

So on my (then) new TI-89 I had that big screen, but the calculator only let me edit the expression on one row. This I find is a really BIG mistake on the TI-89:s user interface.

Well, as time passed on I learned to use Apps->Text Editor instead. Just make a quick Copy and then 2ND |<-|->| to move between Home and Text Editor, using Copy and Paste. Not ideal, but it works.

I also own a Casio ClassPad 330. I don't know this calculator as good as the TI-89; I mainly bought it because it can do fourier and laplace transformations. But, it seems to have the same problem as the TI-89. With the 330's even bigger screen, I still can't make multi line editing. Yes, as with the TI-89 I can copy the expression to the Program Edit. But since "app switching" isn't as easy and quick as with the TI-89, this is really tiresome.

So fast forward to January 2014. I'm looking to buy a new calculator. Main contenders are the HP Prime and TI-Nspire CX CAS.

I've tried out both calculators emulators on my PC. But again, I can't seem to find ANY way or editor on those that let me do multi line editing?

Every editor or "viewing mode" I try out does NOT wrap the lines. Not even in programming editor, notes, etc... Just that freaking one line and scroll arrows!!!

For me, as a student using the calculator mainly for "calculating", preparing and doing exams, this is totally disturbing! How can the calculator makers miss such a obvious thing that is at the core of what a calculator is intended to be used for?

****Since my calculator has to be "clean and cleared" for exams, I can't use any extra software on the calculator, such as an extra editor etc.****

Am I wrong? Am I missing something on any of the calculators?
 *.*

What do you think?

Since I own the original TI-89 I'm thinking of buying a TI-89 Titanium, is this my only option?

Pages: [1]